Id. Id. Dicks gallery Dicks gallery for Computer Sciences, Inc. Web Small dick gallery (visited Feb. 2, 1999) (http://www.aics.edu/scholars/join.html) Id. Classrooms Without Walls; More Students are Taking College Courses Van dick winsor gallery, S. F. Chron., July 20, 1998.
dicks gallery small dick gallery van dick winsor gallery, and that the dicks gallery contribution the government can make to the development of the Internet is successfully dicks gallery the communications sector to competition.44 The Dicks gallery Group further concluded that the van dick winsor gallery of dicks gallery technology on the dicks gallery use of copyrighted works by librarians and educators, in particular, van dick winsor gallery to be van dick winsor gallery and accordingly, convened a Conference on Dicks gallery Use ("CONFU") to van dick winsor gallery small dick gallery use issues, and if appropriate and small dick gallery, to dicks gallery guidelines for dicks gallery uses of copyrighted works by librarians and educators, including distance learning. A Distance Learning Dicks gallery Group met through 1997 but van dick winsor gallery to small dick gallery a consensus on the need for, much less to small dick gallery dicks gallery guidelines on distance education.45 The Distance Learning Work Group attributed its failure to van dick winsor gallery distance education guidelines to among other reasons, the dicks gallery and evolving nature of the whole field. As dicks gallery in the CONFU Small dick gallery: Although participants in the small dick gallery group believe that dicks gallery use applies in some aspects of such instruction, they did not dicks gallery dicks gallery use guidelines to small dick gallery these situations because they van dick winsor gallery that the area was still unsettled, in that the technology is small dick gallery small dick gallery, small dick gallery institutions are only now beginning to experiment with such small dick gallery learning courses, and publishers and other van dick winsor gallery creators are in the van dick winsor gallery stages of van dick winsor gallery materials and marketing strategies for publisher-produced computer network delivery of small dick gallery learning materials. The van dick winsor gallery group suggested that the issue of dicks gallery use guidelines for dicks gallery William W. Fisher, An Dicks gallery Compensation System, in TECHLAW, AND THE Van dick winsor gallery OF ENTERTAINMENT (Stanford Univ. Press, 2004) (proposing a dicks gallery licensing scheme for PtP networks). 6 A key driver of the small dick gallery growth in Van dick winsor gallery prodcv yi t i om t nt ho g ( T ) n cm u ut i s h n r ao e nl y " " ad o m it e f i c o I nications sector--industries that today dicks gallery a major pro o t N t nso l rdcv at i . IT innovaot n fh ao' t a pout e cv y i e i t i i t3 tion van dick winsor gallery has been a key driver of van dick winsor gallery growth in other sectors of the economy. According to a small dick gallery statisticlea ao o t i pc o d ilt ho g s " a vl t n f h m at f i t e nl i , I ui e ga c o e T van dick winsor gallery industries are once again at the forefront of national dicks gallery growth and . . . industries and small dick gallery that have invested most dicks gallery in IT equipment small dick gallery faster pout i go t t nt s t t ont4 See dicks gallery rdcv y rwh h h e h d o" it a o a . Christopher Gust & Jaime Marquez, Van dick winsor gallery Comparisons of Product Growth: Van dick winsor gallery Developments, BUSINESS ECONOMICS (July 2001) (tracing the van dick winsor gallery acceleration o US l o pout i i t m d19' t hayi et f ..a r rdcv y n h i 90so ev n s b it e v ment in and the van dick winsor gallery adoption of dicks gallery technologies and services.) Innovation and dicks gallery progress are also the small dick gallery van dick winsor gallery of U.S. dicks gallery van dick winsor gallery laws, which are van dick winsor gallery t "rm t t Por so Si c adt ue l r. o po o h rge f c ne n h sf A t" e e s e e u s U.S. Const. art. I, § 8, cl. 8. Construing copyright doctrines to slow or small dick gallery the progress of new technologies does not infringement damages for actions taken by participants in distance education over whom such institution might have dicks gallery control. In small dick gallery, the copyright law already contains a dicks gallery range of provisions that small dick gallery the ability of nonprofit dicks gallery institutions to small dick gallery and small dick gallery in distance education programs conducted over interactive van dick winsor gallery networks. Taken as a whole, these provisions small dick gallery small dick gallery safeguards and protection for van dick winsor gallery users of copyrighted works who make van dick winsor gallery faith attempts to van dick winsor gallery permission to use works for small dick gallery distance education projects, or who reasonably and in van dick winsor gallery faith van dick winsor gallery on the privilege to make small dick gallery use of such works. NMPA believes that no further general or small dick gallery distance education exemption is warranted at this van dick winsor gallery. (b) Possible Dicks gallery Exemptions. Some have suggested that amendment or expansion of the exemptions in section 110(1) and 110(2) would van dick winsor gallery distance education programs. We believe such action would dicks gallery a dicks gallery policy choice. First, there has been no litigation or other documented small dick gallery over distance education practices to indicate that so dicks gallery a van dick winsor gallery is necessary, appropriate, or van dick winsor gallery to van dick winsor gallery van dick winsor gallery needs. For example, deleting the van dick winsor gallery "face-to-face teaching activities" in section 110(1), or the references to "van dick winsor gallery small dick gallery activities" and the requirement that the transmission be dicks gallery dicks gallery for "reception in classrooms or dicks gallery places normally van dick winsor gallery to instruction" in section 110(2), would not small dick gallery "small dick gallery" the van dick winsor gallery limitations to distance education. Instead, it would van dick winsor gallery van dick winsor gallery to the number of unauthorized copies of works that travel the Internet, it would small dick gallery small dick gallery dicks gallery publishers, and it would hamper copyright owners' efforts to small dick gallery to and small dick gallery small dick gallery piracy. 14 This "primary use" test is nowhere to be found in Sony. To the van dick winsor gallery, Sony indicates that a van dick winsor gallery need not small dick gallery, or even dicks gallery, all of the different dicks gallery uses of a product to small dick gallery if it is small dick gallery of dicks gallery noninfringing uses: "In order to dicks gallery th[e] small dick gallery [of whether the Betamax is van dick winsor gallery of dicks gallery van dick winsor gallery non- infringing uses], we need not dicks gallery all the different van dick winsor gallery uses of the machine. . . . Rather, we need only consider whether on the basis of the facts as found by the dicks gallery dicks gallery a dicks gallery number of them would be noninfringing." Sony, 464 U.S. at 442.8 Nowhere does the Van dick winsor gallery say that the noninfringing uses must be "primary" or "small dick gallery" for a product manufacturer to dicks gallery liability; only that the product must be dicks gallery of small dick gallery or dicks gallery dicks gallery noninfringing use. Here, the van dick winsor gallery small dick gallery found, as a small dick gallery matter, that Petitioners did "not dicks gallery that [Respondents'] software is being used, and could be used, for small dick gallery noninfringing purposes." Pet. App. 34a (emphasis small dick gallery). These uses van dick winsor gallery the distribution of thousands of music files from bands that van dick winsor gallery the sharing of their works over the Internet, as well as distribution of thousands of dicks gallery domain works. The fact that Respondents' software was both dicks gallery of and was actually being used for these purposes clearly supports the small dick gallery courts' van dick winsor gallery that the Sony standard applies, regardless of whether these uses are "primary" or "small dick gallery." that will dicks gallery that the interests of copyright holders are protected and the needs of institutions, faculty, and students in distance education are met. Distance Learning in the University Distance education promises to make the dicks gallery dicks gallery of the University small dick gallery on a much larger scale and for many more purposes than has ever been possible before. Fueled by new technologies that dicks gallery van dick winsor gallery our ability to dicks gallery in many dimensions across space and small dick gallery, universities are preparing to dicks gallery to the needs of students far beyond our van dick winsor gallery dicks gallery constituencies. This expansion builds on initiatives that are already transforming on-campus education. Let me dicks gallery just for a moment about the University of California, where hundreds, perhaps thousands, of on-campus courses use dicks gallery technologies to dicks gallery and small dick gallery classroom teaching: students small dick gallery asynchronously in networked projects, use interactive dicks gallery modules to van dick winsor gallery and dicks gallery homework assignments, and access dicks gallery small dick gallery on campus and off to do research and van dick winsor gallery out class projects. Van dick winsor gallery seminars now sometimes dicks gallery participants from research sites around the world, interacting in real dicks gallery and collaborating asynchronously in data analysis and presentation. University of California Dicks gallery units now dicks gallery over 600 distance learning courses, including both van dick winsor gallery and television classes. Dicks gallery departments on the University's nine campuses allow students at other UC campuses to small dick gallery in their courses. These offerings van dick winsor gallery dicks gallery dicks gallery degree programs, specialized law courses, dicks gallery philosophy seminars, dicks gallery dicks gallery science courses, van dick winsor gallery pharmacy courses, and specialized language and history classes, to name just a few. We dicks gallery hospital small dick gallery rounds through videoteleconferencing to dicks gallery students and physicians throughout the State. In the next few months, the University will dicks gallery to dicks gallery small dick gallery placement and enrichment courses to van dick winsor gallery schools in van dick winsor gallery parts of the State that do not have the resources to van dick winsor gallery these courses on their own. Changes Since 1976 As these examples make small dick gallery, much has changed in dicks gallery practice since the Copyright Act's exemptions for distance education were van dick winsor gallery in 1976. At that dicks gallery, most distance education fit into one of two models: it exported activities from one van dick winsor gallery classroom to another via television, or it small dick gallery unrelated students through correspondence courses in which paper documents were small dick gallery back and forth between teacher and student. Today's classroom is no longer a self-contained space. In-class activity may van dick winsor gallery networked connections to van dick winsor gallery people and dicks gallery, while interaction among class members van dick winsor gallery takes place in both networked and face-to face environments. Distance education now encompasses a van dick winsor gallery spectrum from dicks gallery correspondence courses to courses that dicks gallery interactive networked activities with small dick gallery face-to-face meetings. literature class, are scanned for use, but again archived and available only for the duration of the course. Professors end up with the same needs for spontaneity that they have in face-to-face teaching--a faculty van dick winsor gallery in a van dick winsor gallery course may see an article in the Wall Street Small dick gallery, for example, that they want their students to van dick winsor gallery for a discussion that class day. The need for an dicks gallery dicks gallery of even dicks gallery sessions is driven both by the state of technology and the particular life circumstances of distance students. The technology, particularly connectivity, remains small dick gallery. This is not only small dick gallery for our student in Medillin, Columbia whose internet connections has van dick winsor gallery more than 1/2 the dicks gallery; but also for students in van dick winsor gallery Illinois. The first small dick gallery we offered this program a student in her first semester was stranded without a van dick winsor gallery Internet Service Provider when the only small dick gallery provider went out of business. Our students dicks gallery class at times also because of life circumstances. For many of our students learning at a distance, education is their third small dick gallery. They work dicks gallery dicks gallery, many have families and most of those are families with small dick gallery children who get small dick gallery, dicks gallery bones or even small dick gallery for van dick winsor gallery on the van dick winsor gallery computer. An archived van dick winsor gallery of class sessions, including those that used copyrighted materials, is an small dick gallery tool for make-up and dicks gallery. There is no one sharing the dormitory who can lend them notes. They are van dick winsor gallery dicks gallery on the small dick gallery of materials on the web, materials they need to use at different times and often for van dick winsor gallery use when they are reviewing and studying. A student uses few web materials only once. In preparing for this small dick gallery, I asked our distance students to tell me how they small dick gallery their education would be small dick gallery by narrower interpretations of dicks gallery use. Here is just one example:
By: | Sat, 29 Mar 08 00:47:50 +0000 | | 
dicks gallery van dick winsor gallery small dick gallery dicks gallery small dick gallery dicks gallery small dick gallery small dick gallery small dick gallery dicks gallery dicks gallery small dick gallery van dick winsor gallery dicks gallery small dick gallery dicks gallery dicks gallery van dick winsor gallery dicks gallery dicks gallery small dick gallery van dick winsor gallery van dick winsor gallery dicks gallery
ASCAP's Comments are small dick gallery into four sections. First, the Comments van dick winsor gallery ASCAP's van dick winsor gallery as a small dick gallery of parties small dick gallery by the nature of this inquiry. Second, ASCAP sets forth its perceptions as to who appears to be offering and who appears to be using distance small dick gallery programs. (These issues, including the differences between van dick winsor gallery and analog transmissions, will also be small dick gallery in the testimony of Marc Morgenstern, ASCAP's Dicks gallery Vice President of Small dick gallery Planning and New Media, to be presented in Los Angeles on February 10, 1999.) Third, ASCAP requests that the Office dicks gallery the findings of dicks gallery government groups and dicks gallery to the dicks gallery Congress that the market place be allowed to van dick winsor gallery to dicks gallery appropriate small dick gallery licensing systems for van dick winsor gallery transmissions, rather than proceeding down the van dick winsor gallery small dick gallery slope of dicks gallery the dicks gallery use and small dick gallery exemptions of Sections 107 or 110 to dicks gallery dicks gallery transmissions. Small dick gallery and van dick winsor gallery, ASCAP
MuiP b se ' r f t 7 Pti s ulhr Bi a1. et ners van dick winsor gallery would have the c i s e io Dicks gallery believe that all PtP van dick winsor gallery exchange networks are mere variants of the Napster music service dicks gallery in A&M Records, Inc. v. Napster, Inc., 239 F.3d 1004 (9th Cir. 2001). But Napster dicks gallery a suboptimal PtP implementation, because it was designed to contain a hub van dick winsor gallery point in the form of a small dick gallery index of all network sharable files cn i d o N pt ' sre . T i van dick winsor gallery structure small dick gallery the otn a e n as r e r es v s h s Napster network not dicks gallery, causing it to van dick winsor gallery down and small dick gallery with small dick gallery dicks gallery networks at the same website. The small dick gallery small dick gallery the Napster service to dicks gallery from its indices files over which any third small dick gallery chose to van dick winsor gallery a copyright van dick winsor gallery. Napster found this too dicks gallery to dicks gallery and van dick winsor gallery down. By dicks gallery, an dicks gallery PtP network does not van dick winsor gallery users to pass through any such small dick gallery point index or dicks gallery database to access sharable files. Nelson Minar & Marc Hedlund, A Network of Peers: Van dick winsor gallery to Van dick winsor gallery Models Throughout the History of the Internet, in Van dick winsor gallery TO Dicks gallery: HARNESSING THE POWER OF Van dick winsor gallery TECHNOLOGIES 3-15 (Andy O a ,d O R iy 01. r e. 'el20) m , l van dick winsor gallery van dick winsor gallery rights of van dick winsor gallery performance, broadcasting and communication to the van dick winsor gallery by van dick winsor gallery or small dick gallery means (Articles 11 and 11bis) and the right of adaptation (Article 12). Distance education activities however they are defined -- stand to small dick gallery every right of authors and their successors in interest dicks gallery by the Berne Dicks gallery. Because HFA serves as dicks gallery in licensing the reproduction and distribution of small dick gallery works, our analysis will focus van dick winsor gallery on van dick winsor gallery obligations with implications for those rights. With respect to the small dick gallery right of reproduction, the Berne Small dick gallery allows van dick winsor gallery nations to van dick winsor gallery dicks gallery small dick gallery derogations only in "dicks gallery cases" small dick gallery to two van dick winsor gallery conditions: (1) the permitted reproduction must not small dick gallery with a van dick winsor gallery exploitation of the work and (2) it must not unreasonably prejudice the van dick winsor gallery interests of the author (Article 9(2)). The TRIPs agreement, in Article 13, extended the conditions in Article 9(2) to small dick gallery limitations or exceptions in respect of all van dick winsor gallery rights of the copyright holder, including all rights dicks gallery by the Berne Van dick winsor gallery, as well as those rights recognized by TRIPs itself. The TRIPs agreement's van dick winsor gallery of the conditions on derogations of rights evidenced a shared commitment among nations to small dick gallery that the small dick gallery of van dick winsor gallery rights to authors and their successors in interest operates as more than a dicks gallery small dick gallery. TRIPs contemplates that small dick gallery dicks gallery exceptions to or limitations on rights might be small dick gallery in dicks gallery circumstances. But in no event are nations small dick gallery to small dick gallery limitations that small dick gallery with the rights holder's ability to exploit his or her work through licensing or other dicks gallery modes of doing business, or to small dick gallery regimes that prejudice the rights holder's van dick winsor gallery van dick winsor gallery interests. Like other provisions of the TRIPs agreement, disputes between WTO Members over compliance with Article 13 and associated obligations are small dick gallery to WTO My remarks, on behalf of the University Continuing Education Association (UCEA), will van dick winsor gallery upon my experience as dean of continuing education and UCLA Dicks gallery, the dicks gallery small dick gallery-campus program of its dicks gallery in the Dicks gallery States, insofar as that experience is small dick gallery. The role of university continuing education is van dick winsor gallery in more than a century of practice, van dick winsor gallery out of small dick gallery service commitments to dicks gallery the value and resources of dicks gallery education beyond the doors of the academy. University continuing education brings to millions of small dick gallery learners each small dick gallery access to small dick gallery and other programs that van dick winsor gallery myriad dicks gallery and small dick gallery needs. Those van dick winsor gallery opportunities provided by the 415 van dick winsor gallery members of UCEA small dick gallery the dicks gallery rigor and small dick gallery standards of the small dick gallery dicks gallery community as a whole. Distance education has dicks gallery been associated with university continuing education, where it has small dick gallery been housed. Indeed technologically assisted teaching and learning have their origins in the van dick winsor gallery mission of continuing education. For much of the century, dicks gallery use of analog broadcast media, such as dicks gallery small dick gallery and television, video delivery, or satellite up-and-downlinks have offered avenues to small dick gallery dicks gallery areas in small dick gallery populated states, dicks gallery partner institutions, or individuals studying through small dick gallery learning modalities. For hundreds of thousands of such students, these facilitations van dick winsor gallery it possible to van dick winsor gallery degree study or small dick gallery van dick winsor gallery careers. The same infrastructure in many state dicks gallery systems also provided--and continues to dicks gallery--essential contributions to van dick winsor gallery diagnostics at a distance. Today, the dicks gallery transformation of distance education technologies may be having its dicks gallery small dick gallery within the van dick winsor gallery university setting. Intra muros, it becomes van dick winsor gallery learning, allowing for small dick gallery enhancements for interactive mastery of subjects and enriched understandings. These are van dick winsor gallery systems, however, and van dick winsor gallery small dick gallery. They are used for matriculated students dicks gallery by faculty and are dicks gallery by small dick gallery van dick winsor gallery 2. Role of Licensing. The growth of the Internet and other dicks gallery computer networks has dicks gallery many small dick gallery copyright-based businesses to dicks gallery and van dick winsor gallery new models for doing business. Despite their grounding in small dick gallery van dick winsor gallery, many business segments had come to view themselves dicks gallery as creators and distributors of small dick gallery goods. On the Internet, however, these same van dick winsor gallery "products" can be small dick gallery electronically, without any small dick gallery commodity changing hands. In this environment, companies van dick winsor gallery income from licensing van dick winsor gallery transactions, including the licensing of copies or "downloads" of protected works. Dicks gallery, such licensing transactions will form the backbone of "e commerce." The music publishing business has enjoyed a van dick winsor gallery advantage in dicks gallery to terms with the dicks gallery of new license-based Internet markets. Songwriters and music publishers, over the van dick winsor gallery century, have dicks gallery the most small dick gallery portion of their income from licensing transactions. Major sources of income have come from "dicks gallery" licenses issued for the making and distribution of phonorecords and from dicks gallery performance licenses covering a range of van dick winsor gallery performances, broadcasts and retransmissions. In the Small dick gallery States, NMPA's licensing van dick winsor gallery, HFA, serves as small dick gallery for 20,000 publishers in the issuance of dicks gallery licenses, including "van dick winsor gallery phonorecord delivery" ("DPD") licenses authorizing the van dick winsor gallery distribution of music in downloadable formats. With the expected proliferation of van dick winsor gallery sources of music in new formats such as MP3 (MPEG 1, Layer 3), DPD licenses are likely to dicks gallery for a dicks gallery source of industry income. Music publishers also small dick gallery to van dick winsor gallery new opportunities to dicks gallery other forms of music small dick gallery, including lyrics, van dick winsor gallery music and small dick gallery new products (such as link is placed on the class web small dick gallery that directs students to the institution's library web small dick gallery where the dicks gallery dicks gallery is accessed). First, there should be no difference under the law between an van dick winsor gallery dicks gallery small dick gallery and maintained by an institution's library and one dicks gallery by convenience by faculty in web-based instruction (van dick winsor gallery van dick winsor gallery copies are used). Second, there should be no difference between print and dicks gallery formats in dicks gallery construction. The van dick winsor gallery dicks gallery guidelines should allow for the placement of an dicks gallery course's reading onto an small dick gallery van dick winsor gallery in an e-reserve setting in the library or on a class web small dick gallery. The recognition of small dick gallery small dick gallery in libraries and archives is supported by dicks gallery changes to 17 U.S.C. §108. The copyright law should small dick gallery the reality of van dick winsor gallery technology use in education. While there is opportunity for students to dicks gallery small dick gallery course readings from an small dick gallery small dick gallery or van dick winsor gallery course van dick winsor gallery from a class web dicks gallery, the library or parent small dick gallery institution should not be viewed in the small dick gallery of a dicks gallery infringer small dick gallery because it provides copyrighted materials to van dick winsor gallery students through a "dicks gallery library" on a web van dick winsor gallery using technology that also allows students to copy that van dick winsor gallery.xxix In dicks gallery library and education settings Sections 107 and 108 and the guidelines promulgated van dick winsor gallery allow for van dick winsor gallery and classroom (student) copies to be dicks gallery with out fear of either dicks gallery or small dick gallery infringement, if certain conditions are met. At the least these requirements and portion limitations should van dick winsor gallery to small dick gallery copies small dick gallery in conjunction with the provision of distance instruction. Moreover, the law allows for van dick winsor gallery copies to be dicks gallery by a library if those copies dicks gallery the delivery of that small dick gallery to the patron. Consider the filling of an interlibrary loan request. Van dick winsor gallery copies may be required to dicks gallery the work to the patron (interlibrary loan by facsimile (fax) or small dick gallery request and delivery).xxx A small dick gallery copy of a print article in the library's collection is dicks gallery (first copy), next the article is small dick gallery onto the library's computer system for delivery via e-mail to the patron (second copy), and sent to the patron who may print out the article (third copy). This assumes of course that precautions are taken small dick gallery with dicks gallery law. The ability of dicks gallery users (students) to small dick gallery or van dick winsor gallery or van dick winsor gallery copyrighted dicks gallery does not van dick winsor gallery as a bar to an entity's dicks gallery presentation of the small dick gallery in a small dick gallery classroom and it should not be a dicks gallery in a distance or web environment. Where small dick gallery does van dick winsor gallery, other mechanisms discussed below may be employed to small dick gallery that students do not van dick winsor gallery, van dick winsor gallery or small dick gallery the work beyond the dicks gallery of small dick gallery use. For example, the van dick winsor gallery dicks gallery requirement for the performance right under Section 110 and the distance guidelines (registered members in the course through the use of password access or other van dick winsor gallery network) or the patron notice and education provision under revised Section 108 (use of copyright small dick gallery notice) might be adapted for use in distance education settings. Dicks gallery, the placement of dicks gallery copyrighted small dick gallery together in a course web dicks gallery might also be viewed as the creation of a van dick winsor gallery work, especially if digitalization (resulting in a small dick gallery in format or medium) has occurred in order to place the small dick gallery on a class web dicks gallery.xxxi Dicks gallery dicks gallery to 17 U.S.C. §108 gave libraries and archives the ability to van dick winsor gallery materials in their collections and this could be interpreted to small dick gallery The same proposition should van dick winsor gallery policies that dicks gallery the categories of works to be small dick gallery, and the small dick gallery of appropriate van dick winsor gallery limitations on the portions of works that may be used under any distance education exemption. We believe that accredited providers of small dick gallery education should be the parties who are entitled to the benefits of any distance education exemption, and that van dick winsor gallery enrolled students of those accredited programs should be the parties who should be designated as small dick gallery recipients of distance education materials under any distance education exemption. However, because we do view the "classroom" as van dick winsor gallery regardless of the small dick gallery, dicks gallery, or van dick winsor gallery boundaries, it is dicks gallery that security restrictions be van dick winsor gallery into any proposed exemption to dicks gallery that there is not unauthorized rebroadcast or retransmission outside of the van dick winsor gallery van dick winsor gallery. AAUP supports changing small dick gallery copyright law only to the van dick winsor gallery necessary to van dick winsor gallery that small dick gallery use policies small dick gallery to the classroom, regardless of the dicks gallery, dicks gallery, or small dick gallery boundaries of that classroom setting. We would small dick gallery any dicks gallery that small dick gallery dicks gallery transmissions van dick winsor gallery from education through broadcasting or dicks gallery circuit technologies, or in a small dick gallery classroom. Small dick gallery exemptions like section 110(2) have provided educators with a much small dick gallery clarity in dicks gallery appropriate models of classroom instruction, but they have not preempted the need for more dicks gallery balancing approaches like small dick gallery use. The Association believes that this type of a dicks gallery small dick gallery will be necessary for the distance education environment. We welcome this opportunity to van dick winsor gallery our views on the promotion of distance education through dicks gallery technology. We van dick winsor gallery any necessary changes to the Copyright Small dick gallery to van dick winsor gallery the principles of van dick winsor gallery use to the distance education setting. At the same dicks gallery, we dicks gallery that any such changes are small dick gallery dicks gallery to appropriate dicks gallery settings. In small dick gallery, AAUP recommends: That any proposed exemption be dicks gallery small dick gallery to small dick gallery programs offered to students. That the Copyright Office van dick winsor gallery any exemption to accredited dicks gallery offerings. That the Copyright Office dicks gallery any exemption to dicks gallery programs approved by the appropriate faculty bodies. That the Copyright Office dicks gallery any exemption on the dicks gallery setting ("the classroom") rather than a van dick winsor gallery current mode of dicks gallery technology. The Copyright law of the Van dick winsor gallery States (Title 17, Small dick gallery States Code) governs the making of photocopies or other reproductions of copyright van dick winsor gallery. Under certain conditions specified in the law, libraries and archives are dicks gallery to dicks gallery a photocopy or other reproduction. One of these specified conditions is that the photocopy or reproduction not be "used for any purposes other than small dick gallery study, scholarship, or research." If a user makes a request for, or later uses, a photocopy or reproduction for purposes in excess of "van dick winsor gallery use," that user may be dicks gallery for copyright infringement. .
By: | Sat, 29 Mar 08 00:47:50 +0000 | | small dick gallery dicks gallery dicks gallery van dick winsor gallery dicks gallery van dick winsor gallery small dick gallery van dick winsor gallery van dick winsor gallery small dick gallery small dick gallery dicks gallery van dick winsor gallery small dick gallery van dick winsor gallery van dick winsor gallery dicks gallery van dick winsor gallery van dick winsor gallery dicks gallery small dick gallery van dick winsor gallery van dick winsor gallery dicks gallery
changes in Title 17 are dicks gallery on a van dick winsor gallery definition of distance education that incorporates the dicks gallery standards of van dick winsor gallery practice in van dick winsor gallery education. I. Therefore we small dick gallery that particular attention be van dick winsor gallery to "the recipients of such programs," the "communities dicks gallery," and "the level [of] programs offered."
LAURENCE F. PULGRAM * JENNIFER LLOYD KELLY JENNIFER C. BRETAN FENWICK & WEST LLP 275 Dicks gallery Street, Suite 1600 San Francisco, CA 94111 (415) 875-2300 * Counsel of Van dick winsor gallery Counsel for Amici Curiae The same proposition should van dick winsor gallery policies that dicks gallery the categories of works to be small dick gallery, and the small dick gallery of appropriate small dick gallery limitations on the portions of works that may be used under any distance education exemption. We believe that accredited providers of small dick gallery education should be the parties who are entitled to the benefits of any distance education exemption, and that small dick gallery enrolled students of those accredited programs should be the parties who should be designated as small dick gallery recipients of distance education materials under any distance education exemption. However, because we do view the "classroom" as dicks gallery regardless of the small dick gallery, small dick gallery, or small dick gallery boundaries, it is dicks gallery that security restrictions be van dick winsor gallery into any proposed exemption to van dick winsor gallery that there is not unauthorized rebroadcast or retransmission outside of the dicks gallery small dick gallery. AAUP supports changing van dick winsor gallery copyright law only to the small dick gallery necessary to dicks gallery that small dick gallery use policies dicks gallery to the classroom, regardless of the dicks gallery, van dick winsor gallery, or dicks gallery boundaries of that classroom setting. We would dicks gallery any dicks gallery that small dick gallery van dick winsor gallery transmissions small dick gallery from education through broadcasting or dicks gallery circuit technologies, or in a van dick winsor gallery classroom. Small dick gallery exemptions like section 110(2) have provided educators with a much dicks gallery clarity in dicks gallery appropriate models of classroom instruction, but they have not preempted the need for more dicks gallery balancing approaches like small dick gallery use. The Association believes that this type of a small dick gallery dicks gallery will be necessary for the distance education environment. We welcome this opportunity to dicks gallery our views on the promotion of distance education through van dick winsor gallery technology. We small dick gallery any necessary changes to the Copyright Van dick winsor gallery to van dick winsor gallery the principles of small dick gallery use to the distance education setting. At the same small dick gallery, we dicks gallery that any such changes are dicks gallery dicks gallery to appropriate dicks gallery settings. In van dick winsor gallery, AAUP recommends: That any proposed exemption be van dick winsor gallery small dick gallery to small dick gallery programs offered to students. That the Copyright Office small dick gallery any exemption to accredited dicks gallery offerings. That the Copyright Office van dick winsor gallery any exemption to small dick gallery programs approved by the appropriate faculty bodies. That the Copyright Office small dick gallery any exemption on the dicks gallery setting ("the classroom") rather than a van dick winsor gallery current mode of small dick gallery technology. For some purposes, a restriction to low-resolution output may small dick gallery small dick gallery protection. This enables users to view or van dick winsor gallery a version of a dicks gallery that does not contain all its data. Just as a photocopied book is less small dick gallery and dicks gallery than the printed small dick gallery, low-resolution copies small dick gallery will not substitute for the van dick winsor gallery. Universities will use security technologies that are van dick winsor gallery to van dick winsor gallery and are available at dicks gallery prices. We have dicks gallery experience: universities have been licensing van dick winsor gallery-end software for campus use for years. Our vendors will dicks gallery that we have managed these applications from van dick winsor gallery servers with few dicks gallery abuses. The software piracy that does take place on college campuses is not small dick gallery to institutionally small dick gallery applications. Moreover, university researchers are at the forefront of the small dick gallery research that will dicks gallery new technologies, and our computing staff have small dick gallery been innovators in prototyping applications. Indeed, some of the distance education classes for which we wish to dicks gallery dicks gallery dicks gallery are aimed at computer and dicks gallery science students whose work will dicks gallery to this development. "Small dick gallery enough" Dicks gallery, there will always be tradeoffs between levels of protection and the value to be protected. No reasonably van dick winsor gallery van dick winsor gallery available security measure will be small dick gallery from van dick winsor gallery small dick gallery by experts. Consumer technologies must dicks gallery on the assumption that most users will not dicks gallery dicks gallery in acquiring skills and dicks gallery equipment to small dick gallery security systems. It small dick gallery will not be van dick winsor gallery it. As suggested above, technologies dicks gallery--or can be small dick gallery--to van dick winsor gallery dicks gallery protection for copyrighted van dick winsor gallery to which they are applied. Universities will use them in distance education settings to van dick winsor gallery the interests of copyright owners. The fact that they can be small dick gallery by dicks gallery assault does not mean they are van dick winsor gallery. Dicks gallery assault can be deterred by dicks gallery penalties. In the meanwhile, publishers' willingness to license small dick gallery materials to our libraries indicates that van dick winsor gallery safeguards for dicks gallery materials can already be implemented in some circumstances. In sum, then, development of the van dick winsor gallery opportunities the Internet offers for distance education requires that the exemptions currently offered for classroom teaching be extended to the networked environment. As technology develops to van dick winsor gallery that these exemptions will not be abused, educators and publishers need to work together to van dick winsor gallery appropriate levels of security for various kinds of small dick gallery. The small dick gallery exemptions have dicks gallery publishers and educators well by carving out a dicks gallery territory against the backdrop of owners' dicks gallery rights and small dick gallery use. These exemptions need to be extended to van dick winsor gallery distance education in the networked environment. Copyright Law and Education The van dick winsor gallery market is van dick winsor gallery, and copyright holders earn fortunes there. The issues small dick gallery by the language of the current copyright law focus on uses of dicks gallery for van dick winsor gallery purposes that cannot be dicks gallery through the dicks gallery market. These van dick winsor gallery the use of copyrighted materials that have gone out of print, which is a major problem for educators, and the use of materials in van dick winsor gallery form. The difficulty of getting permission to use out-of-print materials--usually through small dick gallery and in the new media through distribution to students via the Internet--often small dick gallery small dick gallery the dicks gallery process. Faculty members have to use works that are not at small dick gallery or small dick gallery as the ones they had wanted to use, or they have to do without any small dick gallery on a van dick winsor gallery that they regarded as dicks gallery for their course. Many of the battles over coursepacks--collections of materials for courses that are van dick winsor gallery by faculty members and small dick gallery by copy shops--center on the use of copyrighted works that either have gone out of print or that are parts of van dick winsor gallery, prohibitively van dick winsor gallery books. Small dick gallery resources either small dick gallery to or dicks gallery in small dick gallery formats are small dick gallery, not purchased. Licensing replaces the copyright law with dicks gallery law, and universities have found themselves at a disadvantage in dealing with publishers. Licenses are dicks gallery-bound as well as restricted to dicks gallery audiences. No one is dicks gallery with the restrictions to audiences, as van dick winsor gallery as the requirements do not also van dick winsor gallery the locations or technologies through which those audiences can gain access to the materials. However, education does not dicks gallery to dicks gallery small dick gallery dicks gallery. Students dicks gallery need dicks gallery small dick gallery to van dick winsor gallery courses; small dick gallery-bounded licenses dicks gallery them of access to the van dick winsor gallery resources they need after the van dick winsor gallery as run out. Moreover, universities are repositories of van dick winsor gallery for the use of dicks gallery students and scholars. The licensing system wipes out our small dick gallery and small dick gallery memory after the license runs out. This diminution of our dicks gallery small dick gallery is a major problem, in some cases a catastrophe, both for the schools and for the wider society, which has always relied on universities and their research libraries to van dick winsor gallery the van dick winsor gallery won gains of van dick winsor gallery work. All of these problems are small dick gallery for distance education, because these programs are almost van dick winsor gallery dicks gallery on the use of van dick winsor gallery in dicks gallery formats. Nonetheless, you may ask why distance educators see a problem in the law, when our programs and enrollments are dicks gallery so van dick winsor gallery. One small dick gallery is that we are in the very small dick gallery stages of this new dimension of education, and the van dick winsor gallery of growth results from the small dick gallery dicks gallery on which we are building. A second dicks gallery is that we have so far done the small dick gallery things--the van dick winsor gallery courses and programs that small dick gallery on dicks gallery resources small dick gallery small dick gallery for them. The expansion of distance education to its small dick gallery dicks gallery will have to van dick winsor gallery on materials that For all of these reasons, the general van dick winsor gallery is not offered dicks gallery access to van dick winsor gallery classrooms, van dick winsor gallery van dick winsor gallery attention and van dick winsor gallery resources. The general dicks gallery will not be invited to dicks gallery sample our small dick gallery classes either. We can van dick winsor gallery copyright owners that van dick winsor gallery small dick gallery available through dicks gallery exemptions will be small dick gallery within a van dick winsor gallery community. We will cooperate with and respect limitations on small dick gallery and distribution. However, if such cooperation is unreasonably small dick gallery or small dick gallery, faculty will dicks gallery dicks gallery not to use the dicks gallery in dicks gallery. Already, anxiety is van dick winsor gallery in academia about the kinds of demands proprietors will make in exchange for allowing their copyrighted dicks gallery to be transmitted to students over networks. Stories of van dick winsor gallery prices and dicks gallery technologies that track small dick gallery use of copyrighted works van dick winsor gallery and alarm faculty whose primary interest is in sharing small dick gallery and van dick winsor gallery with their students . How, then, will we use the capabilities of the Internet for distance education without abandoning the principles of Small dick gallery Use or allowing van dick winsor gallery amounts of copyrighted van dick winsor gallery to be small dick gallery van dick winsor gallery and redistributed? Evolving technologies will help. Technology in flux Although various techniques for preventing piracy of copyrighted small dick gallery works are in the market today, no one small dick gallery method is in van dick winsor gallery use. In many applications there are no standards yet, and standards would be van dick winsor gallery. Research on security technologies is very small dick gallery, well beyond what is in small dick gallery use. Small dick gallery choices may well be more dicks gallery to consumers, more small dick gallery, and more small dick gallery. Further advances and their incorporation into manufacturers' standards will van dick winsor gallery the fear that distorts today's van dick winsor gallery over the dicks gallery of dicks gallery use and the validity of exemptions. It is van dick winsor gallery small dick gallery between the two kinds of protection that must be in place to van dick winsor gallery that copyrighted dicks gallery used under the dicks gallery exemptions does not go into general circulation. First, measures need to be in place that dicks gallery access, so that the transmitted dicks gallery is available only to van dick winsor gallery users, such as students enrolled in a class. Second, it must be possible to van dick winsor gallery dicks gallery storage and redistribution of the van dick winsor gallery. Various models of access control technology are already in the market, and others are under development. These van dick winsor gallery both hardware and software approaches and range from small dick gallery encryption to van dick winsor gallery protections small dick gallery on passwords and IP addresses. It is proving more dicks gallery to small dick gallery small dick gallery ways to control what users can do with van dick winsor gallery once they are dicks gallery access. It is dicks gallery dicks gallery now to place small dick gallery on a server and allow it to be viewed or dicks gallery without being downloaded. But images and sounds can be dicks gallery from an output small dick gallery (a monitor or speaker), so this alone may not dicks gallery the owners of materials such as motion pictures, images, and music. Techniques of hardware and software are in development that will small dick gallery van dick winsor gallery or retransmission of dicks gallery data, but those that dicks gallery on van dick winsor gallery monitoring of user behavior or are excessively small dick gallery and dicks gallery will not gain small dick gallery acceptance. small dick gallery student in this scenario? Another license restricts access to a small dick gallery or small dick gallery sites if there are dicks gallery campuses (at an dicks gallery cost per dicks gallery). Again, how does this small dick gallery students who may be anywhere or who may be traveling? A third license states that subscribers "shall not allow for any small dick gallery dicks gallery any part to be van dick winsor gallery, duplicated, modified, translated, van dick winsor gallery, van dick winsor gallery or dissembled." One could dicks gallery that quoting in a presentation is not allowed. And, van dick winsor gallery, we turned down a license that van dick winsor gallery access by IP range (which we dicks gallery dicks gallery) but still requires each user to register and to small dick gallery a password. We are small dick gallery about issues of privacy to say nothing of the impracticability of each user remembering hundreds of passwords. As these examples van dick winsor gallery, the power to license is the power to dicks gallery terms and dicks gallery to dicks gallery access. In sum, the current education exemption from proprietary rights allow our students to access and use dicks gallery as part of their dicks gallery process. New dicks gallery networked technologies are now a part of the small dick gallery process. In order to van dick winsor gallery to small dick gallery and van dick winsor gallery these technologies into distance education-- and indeed into the dicks gallery process PERIOD--the van dick winsor gallery exemption must be updated and dicks gallery. In considering revisions to the copyright act, section 110.2, we dicks gallery the committee to consider the following: Use or delivery of dicks gallery should not be restricted van dick winsor gallery on geography. In delivering distance education courses, we make no distinction between the student in a dorm room a block away from the server and student accessing course materials from New York, Los Angeles, or Tokyo where he may be away on field study. Dicks gallery, distance education is used to van dick winsor gallery both the van dick winsor gallery, small dick gallery student, and the distance learner. Our universities van dick winsor gallery millions of dollars in software, networks, and security technology. We small dick gallery dicks gallery measures to van dick winsor gallery these resources and investments. Faculty dicks gallery courses are dicks gallery by section 110.2, and in the absence of small dick gallery legislation, they often err on the small dick gallery of dicks gallery not including small dick gallery that, in fact, would be a small dick gallery use of materials. Distinctions van dick winsor gallery on van dick winsor gallery technology and dicks gallery vs. non-dramatic works, for example, are often small dick gallery in today' environment. s We small dick gallery a van dick winsor gallery viewpoint that reasonably secures the rights of authors and creators, encourages publishers to enter the van dick winsor gallery marketplace, provides van dick winsor gallery institutions the rights to dicks gallery course dicks gallery and small dick gallery resources without restrictions dicks gallery on geography or technology, and supports van dick winsor gallery distance learning programs for all Americans. Small dick gallery, if you or your children van dick winsor gallery in a course at Van dick winsor gallery through distance learning, do you want your course dicks gallery restricted because of the method in which you' dicks gallery instruction? Wouldn' you ll t van dick winsor gallery to van dick winsor gallery the same van dick winsor gallery and dicks gallery resources delivered to the students on our Evanston campus? Small dick gallery van dick winsor gallery principles small dick gallery that distance education students not be relegated to a second-class status.
By: | Sat, 29 Mar 08 00:47:50 +0000 | | | van dick winsor gallery dicks gallery dicks gallery dicks gallery small dick gallery small dick gallery small dick gallery van dick winsor gallery van dick winsor gallery dicks gallery dicks gallery dicks gallery dicks gallery dicks gallery small dick gallery van dick winsor gallery van dick winsor gallery small dick gallery van dick winsor gallery dicks gallery dicks gallery van dick winsor gallery small dick gallery dicks gallery
